Letter To The Editor

Letter to our Editor in Chief,

I was amazed to read in your edition published on December 16th, an item by Hinchinbrook Shire Council, reference pay it forward container collections.

Whilst the Local Government Act of Queensland legalises, what amounts to financial scamming of Ratepayers, I was shocked to see this admission within Councils article.

Whilst a lot of lip service is paid to transparency, honesty, open governance. It must be a first for a Shire Council to admit in print to scamming its ratepayers.

Almost refreshing to see such an admission.

The article explicitly states that a recycling facility is not yet in place. It’s something for the future. But for years our Council has forced on us the rental of recycle bins. Charged

Ratepayers for Recycle bin collections fortnightly, when in fact like many smaller shires all waste regardless of the bin lid colour goes to landfill including returnable containers.

Yes, the Local Government act permits this charging for recycled waste collection, when no recycling exists, and landfill is the only disposal option.

It’s no wonder Politicians are held in such low regard, when even at our local government level we are taken advantage of. Financially scammed.

If the cost of a single waste collection needs to be increased, so be it, do so. Not force a second pointless, optics only bin service on us.

Clearly all our returnable containers have gone to landfill and that is set to continue. It just means we will now no longer bother sorting our recyclables.

It can all go weekly into the Red Bin.

Bob Ford

Taylor Beach

------------------------------------------------

Dear Editor,

Thank you for publishing the letter regarding Council’s recent article on the Containers for Change Pay‑It‑Forward (PiF) stations from Bob Ford, Taylors Beach.

Council strongly rejects the assertion that it is “scamming” ratepayers.

Waste management services, including kerbside waste and recycling collections, are delivered in accordance with Queensland legislation and form part of the overall cost of managing waste responsibly for the community.

Contrary to the claims made, recyclable material placed in yellow‑lid kerbside bins is not sent to landfill.

Council’s kerbside collection vehicles are purpose‑built with two separate compartments, allowing general waste and recycling to be collected simultaneously while remaining fully separated.

All recyclable material collected from yellow‑lid bins is transported to a Materials Recovery Facility in Townsville, where it is sorted and processed for the recovery of recyclable materials.

General waste collected from red‑lid bins is transported separately for landfill disposal.

At no point are these waste streams combined.

Our ratepayers can watch this process during pick up by viewing it on our YouTube channel here: https://youtu.be/DrTJkZmnhME?si=_y23766p8JmmeNKU

This collection system is widely used across Queensland and allows Council to operate efficiently by reducing fuel use, minimising vehicle movements, improving safety, and limiting costs for ratepayers, while still ensuring materials are managed appropriately.

The Pay‑It‑Forward stations referenced in Council’s article are a simple community initiative that encourages the recovery of eligible drink containers through Queensland’s Containers for Change program.

These stations help reduce litter and allow individuals or community groups to collect container refunds if they choose.

Council has also been transparent in acknowledging that additional recycling infrastructure is needed in the region. That is why Council is actively advocating for the development of a local recycling facility at Warrens Hill, which would improve local recycling capacity, increase resource recovery, and extend the operational life of the landfill.

Council remains committed to transparency, responsible waste management, and continual improvement of services for the Hinchinbrook community. Providing accurate information is essential to informed public discussion, and Council encourages residents with questions about waste and recycling services to seek clarification directly.

Mayor Ramon Jayo

Hinchinbrook Shire Council

‍